The Case for Regular Mascara Shop Now If waterproof is the marathon runner of mascaras, regular eye mascara is the reliable daily commuter. Pros Gentler on lashes: The lighter formula makes it a safe choice for everyday wear. Easy removal: Comes off with standard cleansers or micellar water, reducing the risk of lash breakage. More variety: Regular formulas often come in wider options for length, volume, and finishes like glossy or matte. Cons Smudge-prone: A hot day or a little eye-rubbing can leave you with raccoon eyes. Shorter wear: Doesn’t hold up as well to long workdays, parties, or humid weather. Regular eyelash mascara has a balance of good performance, lash health, and convenience rolled into one.